Fairy Tales 2010

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Fathers and Daughters

Why is the parent so crucial in Beauty and the Beast stories, and more specifically, the father? It is in trying to gather Beauty's present that most of the time he encounters the beast, who is angered that his property is being taken. The father has to make a promise to the beast that he will give his daughter to die in his place. Beauty's willingness to sacrifice herself for her father is what shows her virtue and kindness that eventually lead her to loving the beast. However, I found one Beauty and the Beast rendition particularly interesting from the Ashliman site, the story of the Singing Rose from Austria. The father is a king, so the family is not in dire financial trouble, nor does Beauty want for nothing. The father sets a task for his three daughters, that whoever finds the singing rose will become queen. Of course "the youngest and most beautiful of all" ventures into the dark forest, where she gets the rose from an ugly old man. He makes her promise to return to the forest after 7 years. Much like in the Frog King, this girl disregards the promise and doesn't really believe in keeping it. Seven years later, the old man shows up, and the king (although he doesn't want to send his daughter away), makes his daughter keep her promise. In a sense, the father's role in this story and in the Frog King are teaching their daughters lessons of loyalty.
The old man tells the young maiden that if she cuts off his head in three blows, she will be free from his lonely castle. Since this story was in the Beauty and the Beast category, I thought that maybe under the skin of the old man there would be a young prince.
Big, big, disillusionment on my part.
When the queen cuts off his head "The old man's head rolled away on the floor. But behold! Instead of blood, a key fell from the head. It opened all the chests and doors in the entire castle. There the princess found many, many precious things, and she was rich and free forever."
There is no learning to love a Beast; Beauty's kindness and virtue and fidelity do not shine through. In fact, this character of the youngest daughter is not the heroine who gives herself up willingly to save her father and family.

So why is Beauty's father important? He not only "introduces" her to the Beast, albeit accidently, he is the reason she returns home to care for him when he is sick. The Beast can see Beauty's loyalty to her father, and her sadness at not taking care of her father causes him grief, therefore he allows her to visit home on the condition that she return to his care. In seeing her love for her father, the Beast comes to love Beauty, who in turn learns to love him. In most fairy tales the father figure is absent, and it is refreshing to have a tale where he plays a vital role.

2 comments:

  1. The story is definitely very much about love of virtue. Beast is softened by witnessing Beauty's genuine love, something he was not accustomed to, who was in turn softened. One could ask if the love Beauty felt for Beast at that moment was more of a fatherly variety? Which in turn could turn to more of a spousal kind after Beasts transformation of course.
    The other story you read doesn't seem to have much "value" to it. Maybe it's supposed to be a story about that old man or beast or whatever he is searching for someone to kill him and give away his treasure to?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I find the story you found rather intriguing. If Beauty is indeed a princess, how is she going to want for anything in the first place? Perhaps the point of this story is that because Beauty is neither virtuous nor kind, she does not deserve "true love."
    I think the father's place within this set of stories is to be the indirect matchmaker since it is through his actions that Beauty not only encounters the Beast but must also stay with him and learns to love him.

    ReplyDelete